Do you review and edit the work of a professional writer? Having helped start up a writers’ group within the last few months, I am reminded of what constitutes effective feedback for writers.

Writers get frustrated when someone says, “I don’t like this,” or “This is confusing.” This kind of response isn’t specific enough to do the writer any good. An effective writer is thinking about the effect of the communication on the audience and whether it accomplishes its intended purpose.

Here are a few questions you can answer to give specific feedback that particularly helps a technical writer improve content:

  • What’s your first impression? When you look at the presentation of the document, how do you feel? Do the design, typefaces, and so on invite you into the content, or does it turn you away? Do you know where to look first? How does the use of color affect you?
  • What do the title and headings tell you about what the document contains? What do they tell you about the document’s purpose?
  • Do you find yourself reading any sentences or chunks of text multiple times before you understand it? What kept you from understanding the first time?
  • Does the document help you accomplish whatever the title and headings suggest?
  • Do the images help you understand concepts or steps better? What sections of text would be improved with images?
  • How does the tone of the text make you feel? Does it talk to you on your level?
  • Does the document give you all the information you need? Are you left with questions at the end, and if so, does the document tell you where to go to get answers? Or did the document give you too much information?

If you’re a writer yourself and don’t have access to many people to review your work, try leaving the document alone for a while. Then come back and review it with these questions in mind.

Related posts (auto-generated):

  1. Why Writers Should Be Involved Throughout the Project Lifecycle
  2. Careful Observation Adds to Effective Writing
  3. When Tech Writers Don't Read Directions
  4. The Technical Writer Lens
  5. Teaching Project Management How to Work with Technical Writers